Pro Elite Nutrition

NJ Family owned since 2012

Maplewood’s
supplement plug.

Real advice. Real brands. The family-owned shop where competitive bodybuilders and everyday athletes find what the big-box stores never stock.

Shop the StoreVisit Us Today
4.9 on Google · 36 reviewsEst. 2012Special orders welcome

  • Real advice, from the owner

    Maria knows every jar on the shelf and builds the stack around your goal.

  • Same-day local pickup

    Call ahead or order online, then grab it at the counter in Maplewood.

  • 100% authentic stock

    Straight from authorized distributors. Zero gray-market roulette.

  • Secure, private checkout

    Payments run on Stripe. Your card details never touch this site.

  • Special orders, no problem

    Chasing something rare or prepping for a show? If it exists, she hunts it down.

  • A Maplewood staple since 2012

    Family-owned and trusted in the neighborhood for over a decade.

The Shelves

Built for every goal

View all products
Protein & Bars

Protein & Bars

Whey, isolate, vegan blends and the full bar wall

Pre-Workout & Pump

Pre-Workout & Pump

High-stim, non-stim pump and everything between

Fat Burners

Fat Burners

Thermogenics and cut-season staples

Vitamins & Wellness

Vitamins & Wellness

Daily health, herbs, greens and organ support

Shelf Staples

The heavy hitters

A taste of what the shelves hold. The full catalog is coming online; everything below is in store today, and Maria will hold anything at the counter with one call.

Gold Standard Whey
Protein & BarsSold out

Gold Standard Whey

$59.99View product
Athlete clapping chalked hands in a burst of chalk dust under blue light

Why Buy Local

Where the serious lifters shop

Competitive bodybuilders prepping for shows, coaches, and first-timers walking in with a goal: they all end up at the same counter. The shop stocks the serious labels that never make it to big-box shelves, and Maria knows which ones actually earn their price tag.

No warehouse mystery sellers. No gray-market stock with a re-glued seal. Everything comes through authorized distributors, and when something new is worth carrying, it lands here first.

  • Show-prep and contest staples, always in rotation
  • Serious brands the big-box stores never carry
  • Straight answers, zero commission upsell

14

years in Maplewood

4.9★

36 Google reviews

1000s

of stacks built

Meet the Owner

Meet Maria.

In 2012, Maria opened Pro Elite Nutrition with a simple rule: treat every customer like family and never sell them something they don’t need. Fourteen years later, that’s still the whole business model.

Regulars don’t call it a store, they call it her shop. She learns your goal, builds your stack, special-orders anything she doesn’t carry, and remembers what worked when you walk back in. That’s why the reviews keep saying the same two things: knowledgeable, and family.

Come say hi@proelitenutrition
The Pro Elite Nutrition counter with shelves of supplements behind it

Her counter since 2012

1912 Springfield Ave, Maplewood NJ

The Reputation

4.9 stars. Earned slow.

“The best nutrition shop on the east coast.”
The shop’s very first Yelp review, 2014. Still the vibe.
“Maria goes above and beyond for her customers. I will recommend Pro Elite to any of my friends and family. You're treated like family.”
Yelp review, 2025
“The owner Maria was very knowledgeable and honest about all the products she carries. Wish I would have found out about this place sooner.”
Yelp review
“Great selection of products and prices that can't be beat. Don't see what you want? She'll order it.”
Andy, Yelp review
Read all 36 Google reviewsMore on Yelp

On the Gram

Follow the shop

@proelitenutrition

Live feed connects at launch. Tap any tile to see what’s new in store this week.

The Shop

Come see the wall

  • 1912 Springfield Ave

    Maplewood, NJ 07040

  • Call for today's hours

    Quickest answer is always the phone.

  • Pickup, local delivery and shipping

    Same-day pickup at the counter, local delivery around Maplewood, South Orange and greater Essex County, shipping everywhere else.

(973) 313-3140Get directions